Ok, ignore is the wrong word. I have been following news reports and commentary on what is happening with the FLDS (Fundamentalist Latter Day Saints) group in Texas for the past month. To recap for any of you who might have missed it, this group has a ranch in Texas where more than 460 children and their parents lived until a month ago. At that time, the Texas department of Child Protective Services (CPS) led a raid on the compound, including armored personnel carriers and hundreds of officers. The raid was called an emergency by CPS on the basis of an anonymous phone call received 3 days earlier. The caller claimed she was a 16 year old girl who had been forcibly married to an older man. So the basis for the raid was the illegal marriage (thus abuse or rape) of this girl.
As a result of the raid, all 460+ children were removed from the homes on the ranch. Some of these homes were single family residences, with traditional families and small children (i.e. not girls at risk of immediate illegal marriage). Other homes housed multiple wives of one man and their children. It is now clear that at least some underage "marriages" have taken place within these families. (Only one marriage is legal at any given time for these families. The rest are "spiritual" - recognized only within their communities. Kind of like one wife and a mistress or two, but at least the wives know about each other.)
Within 2 weeks, it became clear that the call had been a hoax. The caller was an older woman from another state, and the man named as her "husband" was not in Texas at the time of the raid, and had not been in Texas for YEARS and CPS knew this but proceeded with the raid anyhow.
Now, before I go any further, let me make clear that I think polygamy is awful. I think that the FLDS church, (and the more accepted LDS church, for that matter) are cults. I think the members are seriously deceived. In no way am I advocating that children should be raised in polygamous households or that 15 or 16 year old girls should be told by their "prophet" to marry an older man.
Similarly, however, I am against serial polygamy - i.e. the rampant marriage, divorce, and remarriage that is a feature of our culture. This is no more healthy, and perhaps even more damaging to children than a stable polygamous family. And, looking at Biblical accounts, while God did not plan/design polygamy, it is not condemned nearly as strongly as divorce. Many of the great men of the Bible had many wives, and while I don't think that was God's best plan for them, it did not prevent God from using these men (Solomon and Jacob quickly come to mind).
OK, back to the matter at hand. Now, we have 465 children in the state's custody. The children have been separated from even full blood siblings and have been placed in children's homes and foster homes around the state. Only mothers of children less than 1 year of age have been allowed to stay with or near their children. Even if still nursing, older children were forcibly removed from their mothers. Two children born while their adult mothers were in state custody (CPS refused to accept their birth certificates or driver's licenses as valid ID, and so said the mothers were minors) have been taken into custody by the state.
No one has been charged with abuse in this case. No specific charges have been leveled against any individual at all. I do think that the "husbands" of the minor girls I mentioned above should be charged for violating Texas law. Of course, it would have been helpful if the state had done that first, rather than giving the men a month to flee the state/country.
No one is accusing the mothers of abuse. In fact, written statements by mental health workers who were with the mothers and children in the shelters where they were first held indicate that without exception, the mothers were kind, loving, and excellent parents. The children were well behaved, kind to others, polite, open and curious. Just like healthy children should be.
I won't even go into the abuses that these mothers and children have suffered while in the "care" of CPS.
The reason that this so angers me is that the constitution seems to have been thrown out the window when CPS gets involved. Of course, there are many instances of abuse where children need to be removed from the homes of their abusive or addicted parent(s). But there are also instances where the "tip" used to justify removal of a child was a lie by a jealous ex-spouse or disgruntled employee.
The problem comes when CPS and the parents go to court for the first time. These cases are civil, not criminal, and the burden of proof falls to the parent to prove their innocence, rather than on CPS to prove abuse or neglect. So, in general, I have a problem with CPS as they are not held to the same standards of evidence required for criminal prosecution of abuse. Civil rights are too easily trampled in this way.
But specifically, in this case, I am afraid for the future of my family and all families of conservative faith in our country. Texas CPS has made it clear that for them, this is a case against a belief system, not an abuse case. The prank call was merely the excuse they needed.
So what happens when another group is deemed abusive. Maybe the Amish because they use corporal punishment? Will they take every Amish child from one town or church district or state because they are "at risk"?
How much longer before the state can take any child at any time, without any proof or any due process? I am truly frightened. And even some liberals feel that this action in Texas is WAY over the line, like this
Women's Studies professor from Skidmore.And just to add fuel to the fire, this week, our President signed a bill that requires th
e collection of DNA from all newborns. Excuse me, but the government has no business taking DNA from anyone (except maybe criminals) without their consent.
I am completely indebted to the Headmistress for doing the research on this that I could never do with my pitiful internet connection. All the stuff I've written comes from reading her posts and is better said and well documented there. Mistakes, though, are all mine. Thanks!